Past Recicipents
Distinguished Scholar Award
2020s
- 2024 – Carol Medlicott
- 2023 – Donald E. Pitzer
- 2022 – Deborah Altus
- 2021 – Christian Goodwillie
- 2020 – Kathleen M. Fernandez
2010s
- 2019 – Daniel Patrick McKanan
- 2018 – Dr. William J. Metcalf
- 2017 – Martha Bradley-Evans
- 2016 – No Award Given
- 2015 – No Award Given
- 2014 – Jeff Bach, Young Center for Anabaptist Studies, Elizabethtown College
- 2013 – Susan Love Brown
- 2012 – No Award Given
- 2011 – Rod Janzen
2000s
- 2010 – Eileen Barker
- 2009 – Robert Sutton
- 2008 – Priscilla Brewer, Shaker Communities, Shaker Lives
- 2007 – Janet Zuber, Inspirationalists, The Community of True Inspiration and, Amana Church Society
- 2006 – Carl J. Guarneri, Fourierism and American Utopianism
- 2005 – Gregory Claeys, Owenite, Utopian and Communitarian Studies
- 2004 – Mario De Pillis, Mormon studies
- 2003 – Michael Barkun, Millennialism
- 2002 – Lyman Tower Sargent, Utopian studies
- 2001 – Donald Durnbaugh, Church of the Brethren
- 2000 – Yaacov Oved, Communal Groups
1990s
- 1999 – Timothy Miller, New Religious and Communal Experiments of 19th and 20th Century America
- 1998 – Lawrence Foster, Social and Religious History of the U.S.
- 1997 – Charles Pierce LeWarne, Washington State history
- 1996 – Robert S. Fogarty, American Communal Experiences
- 1995 – No Award Given
- 1994 – No Award Given
- 1993 – Karl J. R. Arndt, Harmony Society and Josephine Elliot, Harmonists and Owenites in New Harmony, IN
- 1992 – Leonard J. Arrington, Mormons
- 1991 – Arthur Bestor, Owenism and Fourierism and Robert Hine, Western Communities
- 1990 – Daniel Patterson, Communal Music
1980s
- 1989 – John Hostetler, Amish Studies and Gertrude Huntington, Hutterite Studies
- 1988 – No Award Given
- 1987 – Ruth Shonle Cavan, Academic Interest and Sociological Research
- 1986 – Julia Neal, Shaker Studies